The Tearoom Library, No. 028 — Girl with a Pearl Earring
Author: Tracy Chevalier
Genre: Historical Fiction · Art History · Literary Fiction
Rating: ★★★★★
Follow-Up Reading:
The Lady and the Unicorn by Tracy Chevalier
Strapless: John Singer Sargent and the Fall of Madame X by Deborah Davis
The Art Thief: A True Story of Love, Crime, and a Dangerous Obsession by Michael Finkel
In the World of Vermeer
Girl with a Pearl Earring is a special novel. It is one of those dignified stories that attempt to tell the life of a famous painter by constructing a fictional backstory around them. I have seen several such novels about the lives of Dutch painter Vincent van Gogh, as well as Claude Monet. It is for good reason, however, that Tracy Chevalier’s novel has become a classic.
It was one of the first “adult” novels I picked up after moving past my Young Adult phase. Rather than making the choice myself, this book seemed to choose me. It was one of my grandmother’s favorite books, and she kept it nearby at all times, admiring the painting on the cover and even reproducing it in her own drawing style. I will talk more about this later in the post.
Johannes Vermeer’s paintings are known for being atmospheric. With only about thirty-four works decisively attributed to him, there are certainly other artists who produced more during their careers. Vermeer’s work took longer because he was meticulous about every detail. He produced only one or two paintings per year—hardly enough to maintain his growing family, a situation that is addressed in Chevalier’s novel.
It is no surprise, then, that Vermeer found himself in debt when he died. His complicated financial situation left his family nearly destitute after his death in 1675, at the age of forty-three. They were forced to sell their home and possessions to survive. His iconic paintings—vastly admired for their warm light and ability to make the ordinary beautiful—could not guarantee financial security.
This is not a fate unique to Vermeer. The arts and the creative life have been both the passion and the undoing of many talented painters and writers who had stories they were eager to tell and show the world, but not the money or patrons to support them. Vincent van Gogh, Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, Percy Bysshe Shelley, and Oscar Wilde all died in debt—or in severe financial hardship.
Griet, Making Art with the Mundane
In Girl with a Pearl Earring, the main character, Griet, is a sixteen-year-old girl living in seventeenth-century Delft. Born into a lower-class family, she is taught the basics of housekeeping—cleaning, laundry, and cooking. She might have been born into an ordinary life of mundane routines, but there is something different about her: she has a sight that other young women lack.
When Johannes Vermeer and his wife, Catharina, first visit Griet’s family home, they find her in the kitchen helping to prepare dinner. Specifically, she is arranging chopped vegetables on a plate, but not in a random manner. Vermeer notices what his wife does not: Griet places the tomatoes in one spot, the cauliflower in another, subconsciously preparing an edible work of art. He understands that she is not merely preparing food, but composing something pleasing to the eye.
The Vermeers have come to her home in search of extra help in their own grand household. Johannes, in particular, needs someone to clean his art studio—his sanctuary, which he does not allow even his own servants to enter. Even Catharina is forbidden from entering the studio, a fact that causes her great distress, for no woman wishes for a place in her own home to be off-limits.
Vermeer, impressed by Griet’s eye for color and arrangement, is convinced at once that she is suited for employment as caretaker in his studio. He believes he can trust her to treat his paintings and materials with care. Catharina does not see Griet as he does; to her, Griet is simply another lower-class girl who will join the household staff and become meddlesome in what is—and is not—her domain.
Griet is quickly hired and told she will move to the Vermeers’ home within a matter of days. She will carry little with her, but she bears great responsibility. Her father, having been blinded in a work accident, can no longer provide for the family; what she earns assisting Vermeer will ensure that her mother and sister have food on the table. So, in spite of her homesickness and trepidation, she courageously takes on this next chapter of her life.
The Painting and the Pearl
Tracy Chevalier wrote an entire novel surrounding Vermeer’s beloved piece, Girl with a Pearl Earring. Using the powerful character of Griet, she built a story behind the painting, spinning a tale to personify Vermeer’s model.
This is historical fiction, so we cannot assume that the model was indeed called Griet. I consider historical fiction beautiful for this very reason: it satisfies our curiosity without claiming to be concrete truth.
In reality, the magic of art is in the fact that we do not know who these models were, why they were chosen, and what took place during the hours, even months, when these beloved paintings were being composed. Girl with a Pearl Earring beautifully marries fact and fiction, satisfying our craving for story without heretically altering what is known about history.
We cannot deny that there may be truth in Chevalier’s story. The model in Johannes Vermeer’s Girl with a Pearl Earring (c. 1665) is believed, by some, to have been a maid or model in his Delft household. It is not a traditional portrait but a tronie—a study of expression, character, and costume rather than a commissioned likeness.
Her identity will forever remain a mystery, because what defines the painting is not who she is, but how she is seen. The girl—this “Griet”—turns toward the viewer as if caught mid-moment, her lips slightly parted. The dark, undefined background removes any sense of setting, isolating her so that attention falls entirely on her face, headscarf, and the single luminous pearl.
Her expression remains ambiguous: neither fully open nor fully withdrawn, it creates a sense of suspended attention. This balance between intimacy and distance is what gives the painting its enduring power, making it feel less like a captured moment and more like an ongoing, silent encounter.
The Painter & the Maiden
Vermeer’s wife, Catharina, is doing all a good wife is expected to do—bearing children, hosting guests—but she is not allowed in her husband’s studio. He is bored of her; it is not clear if he was ever in love with her.
Vermeer seems out of place in his own house, very detached from his many children. His studio is his world. It is where he escapes, where he can make art, taking months and months to finish one project. He takes an interest in Griet, but it is the interest an artist would show in any one thing that fascinates him. He is not lusting for her. In this way, he is also detached. Griet does appear to feel some passion for him, as she enters her sixteenth year, ‘womanhood,’ in his house.
They do not engage in a physical affair, but mentally and emotionally there is a bond he does not have with his wife.
A Note from the Margin
What follows is taken directly from my diary:




